Is your 3PL monthly minimum or card surcharge costing you money?
Minimums and fees7 min read
Compare what you used in a month with the minimum in your contract, and look for a card processing surcharge on any invoice you could pay another way. Neither is usually a billing error: the minimum is a contract term you can renegotiate and the surcharge is a payment choice. The exception is a card surcharge on an invoice you paid by ACH, which is worth asking about.
These are the two lines on a 3PL invoice that look least like errors, which is why they are easy to leave unexamined. A monthly minimum is in the contract, and a card surcharge is on the price list. Nothing is mispriced. The money goes out every month anyway, and a standing charge nobody has looked at is exactly the kind that keeps costing money. This page walks through both: what each one compares, what data it needs, and the cases where it has nothing to say. The same two lines appear in the list of billing errors that show up most often.
Check 1: did you use your monthly minimum?
Some 3PL contracts set a floor on monthly spend. If the services you used in a month add up to less than that floor, the 3PL bills the difference, as a separate line, for example "monthly minimum". You are paying for capacity you did not use.
WareAudit calls this check R10. It adds up the operational charges for the period and compares the total with the monthly minimum in your rate card. Credits and adjustments do not count as usage, and neither does the minimum top-up line itself: counting the top-up would count the shortfall twice. Both numbers are rounded to cents before they are subtracted, so the figures in the report subtract cleanly.
Worked example with made-up numbers, not a typical or quoted minimum and not from our sample report or any customer.
| Line | Made-up example value | How it is worked out |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly minimum in the contract | $2,000.00 | From your rate card |
| Operational charges for the month | $1,200.00 | All charge lines, leaving out credits, adjustments and the top-up line |
| Minimum used | 60% | $1,200.00 divided by $2,000.00 |
| Unused | $800.00 | $2,000.00 less $1,200.00 |
This finding is filed as a saving, not a dispute. The 3PL is within the contract, and the report says so in those words. A letter that demands a credit for a contractual minimum can weaken the rest of the letter. The wording WareAudit puts in the letter instead asks to review the minimum against your current volume, or to discuss which additional services would use it up.
Check 2: is there a card surcharge on the invoice?
Some price lists add a processing surcharge when an invoice is paid by credit card. WareAudit calls this check R11. Three cases produce a finding, and which one applies depends on two things: whether the invoice has a surcharge line, and how it was paid.
| What is on the invoice | What the check does | How it is reported |
|---|---|---|
| A surcharge line on an invoice paid by ACH | Claims the whole line | Dispute, high confidence. The paragraph for your 3PL asks for the amount to be credited. |
| A surcharge line on an invoice paid by card, or paid in a way we do not know | Adds up the surcharge lines, then multiplies the month by 12 | Saving, high confidence: "Paying by ACH removes them." |
| No surcharge line on any invoice in the month, and an invoice paid by card | Estimates 3% of the totals of the invoices paid by card | Saving, low confidence, labeled as an estimate and not as an invoice line |
| No surcharge line on any invoice in the month, and no invoice paid by card | Nothing to report | No finding |
The top row is the one that matters most. If your agreement applies the surcharge to card payments and you pay by ACH, a surcharge line on that invoice is not a payment choice, it is a charge to question. The check treats it that way and files it as a dispute. The second and third rows are about the choice itself: the report turns the monthly figure into a yearly one, because a monthly number sounds tolerable, while the annual figure is the one to weigh against the effort of switching.
The surcharge check in our sample report
Our sample report contains one finding of this kind. It is the third row above: the July 2026 invoice was paid by card, and no invoice in the month carries a surcharge line, so the report estimates it. The sample report has no finding for the monthly minimum check, so there is no sample row for check 1.
| Item in our sample report | Value | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Finding title | Credit card surcharges, $4,389.84 a year | R11 finding |
| Invoice | NW-2026-07, paid by credit card, no surcharge line | Evidence: "Estimate from the invoice payment method" |
| Monthly estimate | $365.82 | 3% of the invoice total, "an estimate, not an invoice line" |
| Yearly figure | $4,389.84 | $365.82 multiplied by 12 |
| Confidence and type | Low confidence, saving | An estimate is filed as a saving, not a dispute |
The 3% is WareAudit's working figure for the estimate, not a number from your contract. Your own rate is in your agreement or price list, so replace the estimate with it before you rely on the total. An estimate is a reason to open the invoice and look, and it is not a credit claim. The paragraph in the letter asks for ACH details and says the figure is estimated at 3%.
What data each check needs
| Needs | Check 1: monthly minimum (R10) | Check 2: card surcharge (R11) |
|---|---|---|
| Outside the invoice | The monthly minimum from your contract, entered in your rate card | How each invoice was paid, card or ACH, as WareAudit records it when the invoice is loaded |
| From the invoices | The charge lines for the whole month | Surcharge lines, if any, and the invoice total for the estimate |
| Result type | Saving, not a dispute | Saving, or a dispute when the surcharge sits on an invoice paid by ACH |
The payment method matters more than it looks. Invoice exports do not say how an invoice was paid, so WareAudit records the payment method when the invoice is loaded. If it is not recorded, the method counts as unknown. When a surcharge line is on the invoice and the method is unknown for every such invoice, the report shows the check as "not checked" instead of guessing. It lists "Credit card surcharges on invoices paid by ACH" under what we could not check, and says why: the invoice data does not say how each invoice was paid. When the method is known for some of them, the report checks those and counts how many it skipped.
When these checks do not apply
- No monthly minimum in the rate card. If the rate card has no minimum, or the minimum is zero, check 1 has nothing to compare against and stays silent.
- You reached the minimum. If usage is at or above the minimum, there is no unused amount and no finding.
- The month is not complete. The minimum is a monthly figure, so the comparison needs the whole month of charges. An invoice that covers part of a month would understate usage, which is why this check waits for the monthly report.
- When the card estimate is made. The 3% estimate is made when no invoice in the month carries a surcharge line and at least one is recorded as paid by card. If any invoice has a surcharge line, those lines are used and the other invoices get no estimate.
- A surcharge line on a card invoice is not a dispute. You chose to pay by card and the price list allows the surcharge, so the finding is a saving to consider, not a credit to request.
- A tiny amount. If the monthly surcharge rounds to $0.00, there is no finding.
What to do with each result
For an unused minimum, look at the trend before the single month. One month at 60% can be a slow season. Six months at 60% means the minimum is set above your real volume, and the conversation to have is at renewal, or sooner if your volume has moved. The question to your 3PL is about the term, not about the invoice.
For a card surcharge, compare the yearly figure with the effort of switching, and ask your 3PL for ACH details. The paragraph WareAudit writes says exactly that: "Could you send the ACH details so we can switch payment methods?" Your agreement decides whether ACH is available and on what terms.
For a surcharge line on an ACH invoice, put it in the claim with your other findings, with the invoice, the line and the amount. How to dispute a 3PL invoice covers the structure of that letter and the timing.
Not legal or accounting advice.
Sources
- WareAudit check R10, unused monthly minimum: the arithmetic, the exclusions and the "within the contract" wording, as built on 2026-10-30.
- WareAudit check R11, card payment surcharge: the three cases, the 3% estimate and the "paid by ACH" dispute, as built on 2026-10-30.
- The numbers in the sample table: the card surcharge finding in our sample report.
- Check 1 example: made-up inputs chosen to show the R10 arithmetic.