3PL receiving fees: where do the free receiving hours go?

Receiving7 min read

If your contract makes some receiving hours free each month, the invoice should credit them on a separate line. WareAudit check R7 (Rule 7 in the report) takes the free hours, multiplies them by the hourly rate on the invoice, subtracts any receiving credit, and asks for what is left. It needs hours and a rate per hour; the free-hour figure from your rate card makes the check exact.

What check R7 compares

Receiving is the work of unloading and checking in your stock at the warehouse. Receiving is often billed by the hour, and it is hard to recount yourself, because nobody on your side was standing in the warehouse with a stopwatch. That is why the contract figure matters: it gives you a number to hold the line against.

R7 reads the hourly receiving lines for the month and the free-hour figure from your rate card. A free-hour figure of N means that N hours of receiving per month are free. They are a free allowance, not a ceiling: hours above them are legitimately billed, and R7 does not ask for those back. What it asks is whether the free hours were charged and never credited:

The credit matters because of how some 3PLs bill. Some 3PLs list every receiving hour at the full rate and credit the free ones on a separate negative line; others bill just the hours above the free ones. One invoice cannot tell these apart, so R7 looks for a credit line in your earlier invoices.

What data it needs

InputWhere R7 reads itIf it is missing
Hours billedThe quantity on each hourly receiving line (receiving labor, unloading, receiving by the hour)The line is not checked
Hourly rateThe unit price on the line, or amount divided by hours when there is no unit price. If lines carry different rates, the lowest is used, and never a rate above your rate card rate for that dateThe line is not checked
Free hours per monthThe receiving free-hours figure in your rate card, taken from the contractR7 switches to a comparison with your own history (below)
Receiving creditsNegative lines in the same month: a negative receiving line, or a credit or adjustment with "receiving" in its nameNo credit is counted, so the full value of the free hours is in question

Receiving billed per unit or per pallet is a different line type, and R7 does not read it. The free-hour figure is also read as hours per month. A contract that gives free hours per shipment or per pallet needs a different calculation, and R7 does not make it.

A worked example from our sample report

In our sample report, the July 2026 invoice has six receiving lines, one per inbound shipment. The rate card says 6.5 hours a month are free.

Receiving line (in our sample report)DateHoursRateBilled
WRO-202607-12026-07-031.68$40.00$67.20
WRO-202607-22026-07-072.51$40.00$100.40
WRO-202607-32026-07-113.13$40.00$125.20
WRO-202607-42026-07-151.03$40.00$41.20
WRO-202607-52026-07-192.15$40.00$86.00
WRO-202607-62026-07-232.00$40.00$80.00
Total, July 202612.5$40.00$500.00
StepIn our sample report
Free hours per month (rate card)6.5
Hours billed in July12.5
Hours that count as free6.5 (the smaller of 12.5 and 6.5)
Value of the free hours6.5 x $40.00 = $260.00
Receiving credit in July$0.00
Still to be credited$260.00

The other 6 hours, $240.00, are billed at the contract rate, and R7 does not question them. In the data behind our sample report (the usual-month figure, the earlier credit lines and the withdrawal note are not on the report page), earlier months carry a receiving credit line named "Receiving - Free Hours Credit", and that is why the finding is rated high confidence. That shows this 3PL bills the hours in full and credits the free ones, so a July with no such line is a missing credit. The letter the engine drafts for the finding names the invoice, the 6.5 free hours, the 12.5 hours billed at $40.00 per hour, and asks for $260.00 to be credited.

When R7 does not work

  • The invoice shows an amount but no hours and no rate. There is nothing to multiply. R7 reports the check as not checked, with the message "The invoice lines do not show how many receiving hours were billed or at what rate", and it does not count toward the number of checks run. In WareAudit's ShipBob API connection, for example, lines arrive with no quantity and no unit price, so this check stays manual there.
  • Some lines have hours and a rate, and others do not. R7 claims from the lines it can check, and the report says how many of the receiving lines it could not check.
  • No credit line anywhere in your history. If none of your invoices shows this 3PL crediting free hours, the 3PL may bill just the hours above the free ones. R7 still shows the finding, but as low confidence and preliminary, with a note to confirm with the 3PL before disputing.
  • The rate card has no free-hour figure. There is no contract number to hold the invoice to, so R7 compares the month with your own history instead. With at least two earlier months, a month whose receiving hours reach three times the usual month (the median) is flagged. The amount is the hours above that usual month at the hourly rate R7 uses, the confidence is medium, and the letter asks the 3PL for timestamped receiving logs rather than for a credit.

If hours and rate are not on the invoice, ask the 3PL for the receiving detail with the hours and the rate, then run the arithmetic above.

How R7 relates to the spike check, R13

R13 is a broader check. It compares each charge type with the median of earlier months, using at least two earlier months, and flags a total at least twice the usual month (scaled for your order volume when order counts are known) and at least $50 above it. It is a catch-all with low confidence: a prompt to ask for a line-level breakdown, not proof of an error.

A receiving bill that jumps can trip both checks. For this pair of checks the engine does not count the same money twice. When a specific rule such as R7 already raises a dispute on a charge type, the R13 spike on that type is withdrawn, and the engine records an internal note saying so.

That happens in the data behind our sample report (the usual-month figure, the earlier credit lines and the withdrawal note are not on the report page). July receiving came to $500.00 against a usual month of $220.00, the median of the five earlier months, and R13 produced a spike on receiving, titled "Spike: Receiving (hour) at 2x a usual month" (2x is the multiple after scaling for July's higher order count). It was withdrawn because R7 had already claimed the receiving hours, and the $260.00 counts once in the total. If R7 cannot run on your invoice, for instance because the lines show no hours, an R13 spike on receiving can still appear as the prompt to ask for the breakdown.

Run the check by hand

  1. 1Find the free receiving hours in your contract, and note whether they are per month, per shipment, or per pallet. The steps below assume per month.
  2. 2Sum the hours on the receiving labor lines for the month, and note the rate on each line.
  3. 3Take the smaller of the hours billed and the free hours, and multiply by the lowest rate on those lines, no higher than the rate on your rate card.
  4. 4Subtract every negative receiving line in the same month.
  5. 5Look for a negative receiving line that credits free hours on an earlier invoice. If none ever appears, ask your 3PL how it bills the free hours before you write.
  6. 6If a positive amount remains, write to your 3PL with the line references, the hours, the rate, and the arithmetic, so the person reading it can check each number.

WareAudit runs this check when the invoice data carries hours and a rate, and says so in the report when it could not. The sample report shows the finding, the lines behind it, and the letter. The rest of the checks are on the checks list, and the errors that show up most often puts receiving next to the others. Not legal or accounting advice.

Sources

  • WareAudit rule R7, "Free receiving hours billed without a credit": formula, inputs, confidence levels and the not-checked messages, as of 2026-10-30.
  • WareAudit rule R13, "Fee spikes over baseline", and the engine step that withdraws a spike already covered by a specific rule, as of 2026-10-30.
  • In the data behind our sample report (the usual-month figure, the earlier credit lines and the withdrawal note are not on the report page): July 2026, invoice NW-2026-07; receiving lines WRO-202607-1 to WRO-202607-6, the R7 finding of $260.00 and the earlier-month median of $220.00 for receiving. See the sample report for the lines and the finding.
  • No 3PL price pages are used in this article.

Have us run these checks on your invoices.

Send three invoices and get the findings in dollars, with the lines behind each one. The first audit is free.

Get a free audit