3PL invoice audit: software, percentage fee or spreadsheet?
Audit options8 min read
There are three ways to audit 3PL invoices: software at a fixed price, an auditor who takes a percentage of what is returned, and a spreadsheet you keep yourself. Software costs the same whatever it finds, a percentage auditor costs a share of what comes back, and a spreadsheet costs your hours. WareAudit is software, so its prices come from its own plan list; the percentages below are for shipping refunds and come from published price lists, October 2026.
How do the three ways compare?
The software column is WareAudit, with prices from its plan list. The middle column describes the percentage model using published price lists, October 2026, without naming providers; where a list shows no price, the column says so. The spreadsheet column is the work you do yourself.
| What you compare | Software at a fixed price (WareAudit) | Auditor paid a percentage | Spreadsheet |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you pay | A fixed price set by order volume, paid by the month or by the year | A share of the amount returned to you; some providers charge a monthly fee instead | No fee; the cost is the hours you spend |
| Price on a published page | Starter $149, Growth $299 and Scale $599 a month, or $1,599, $3,199 and $6,499 a year, in the same order. A one-off audit of three months of bills is $299. See pricing. | Published price lists, October 2026: 25% and 35% of recovered shipping refunds (one list); from $1,000 a month with no setup fee, set in the agreement (one list); no price on the other lists we read | None |
| When you pay | Whether or not the audit finds anything. A refund is available within 14 days of the initial payment, for any reason (refund policy). | On a percentage price the fee follows what is returned. Ask whether there is a minimum, a setup fee or a retainer on top. | When you spend the hours, whether or not a line is wrong |
| What it reads | Line exports from ShipBob or ShipHero invoices and, when you have them, your rate card and earlier invoices; the report says when a check could not run | Invoices and your contract. Ask which fee types and which months it covers. | Whatever you paste in: the invoice export, the contract, your notes |
| Your time | Connect or upload once, then read each month's report and the dispute letter | Hand over invoices and the contract, answer questions, and approve claims if the provider files them | Every month: export, paste, compare each line with the contract, and repeat the checks that need history |
| Who contacts the 3PL | You do. The report includes a dispute letter for you to send; WareAudit does not write to your 3PL. | On the pages we read, providers describe filing the claims for you | You do, with the lines you found |
| What you keep | The report, with the rule number and the invoice lines behind each finding, and the dispute letter | Depends on the provider: ask for the report and the lines behind each claim | The workbook and every formula in it |
What does each way cost for the same amount returned?
A fixed price does not move with what is found. A percentage fee does. The table shows, for each WareAudit annual price, the amount returned in a year at which a 35% fee reaches that price, and the same for 25%. The percentages below come from a price list for shipping-refund audits published in October 2026; auditors of warehouse fees publish no price. Ask for a quote (a percentage, a retainer or a monthly fee) and replace the figure. The table compares prices, not results: it assumes the same amount comes back either way, and neither way can promise an amount. The 3PL decides what it credits.
| WareAudit plan | Order volume | Annual price | Amount returned at which a 35% fee (shipping-refund price list) reaches it | Amount returned at which a 25% fee (shipping-refund price list) reaches it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starter | Up to 3,000 orders a month | $1,599 | $4,569 | $6,396 |
| Growth | Up to 15,000 orders a month | $3,199 | $9,140 | $12,796 |
| Scale | Up to 50,000 orders a month | $6,499 | $18,569 | $25,996 |
Below the amount in its column, the percentage fee comes to less than the annual price; above it, to more. For example, Starter at $1,599 a year equals a 25% fee on $6,396 returned. Two cautions. The 25% and 35% come from the published price lists, October 2026, and the list that shows them covers shipping refunds, not warehouse fees, so replace them with the percentage you are quoted. And a plan is chosen by orders a month while a percentage fee follows what comes back, so the two do not rise together. A spreadsheet has no price on this scale; its cost is the hours in the next section.
What does a spreadsheet catch, and what does it miss?
A spreadsheet can hold any of these checks. What limits it is the data you can get into it and the hours it takes each month. We have not timed a manual audit and give no hours here. In our sample report, one wrong rate on one fee type touched 606 invoice lines, and finding it meant comparing each line with the rate card. The table uses WareAudit rules as examples of what each check needs.
| Check | What the sheet needs | Where a spreadsheet gets hard |
|---|---|---|
| R1, duplicate charges | Invoice lines sorted by order, service, date and amount | A plain duplicate filter flags lines that are legitimate: two parcels or two SKUs of one order at the same amount are different events, so every line needs its SKU and tracking number. |
| R2, recurring surcharges not in the quote | Three or more months of invoices side by side, and the fee names the contract allows | It needs history: a surcharge looks ordinary in any single month. |
| R4, rates above contract | The rate card as a table with start dates, and the unit price on each line | One comparison per line, every month. A price that changes mid-month needs its dates, and a line with no unit price cannot be compared. |
| R5, missing promised credits | A list of the credits the 3PL promised, with dates and amounts, and the credit lines on later invoices | The list has to be kept up for months, and a credit line that settles one promise cannot settle another. |
| R8, peak fees outside the window | Peak surcharge dates from the rate card | The dates have to be in the card. Without them you can find peak fees but cannot say which fall outside the season. |
| R12, shipping markup | The markup cap, and what the carrier charged for each label | The invoice lines have to carry the carrier's own charge for each label; where they do not, you need the carrier statement matched label by label. |
| R13, fee spikes over baseline | Every fee type over several months, and orders per month | A fee that triples when orders triple is not a spike, so the sheet has to divide by orders. With no history there is nothing to compare. |
| R14, orders picked or shipped twice | Per shipment: units ordered, units shipped and tracking, from the 3PL billing export | A second export has to be joined to the invoice by order, and a backorder shipped later is not a repeat. |
| R15, labels above your zone and weight rates | Zone and weight sheets for each service, how fuel is applied, and each label's zone and weight | A two-way lookup for every label; our sample report has 805. In that sample the rule did not run: the rate card has no shipping table, so the labels were not checked, as what a rate card must say notes. A fuel clause that sets a floor rather than a price leaves no rate to compare against. |
Cost per order (R9), the unused monthly minimum (R10) and the card payment surcharge (R11) are closer to arithmetic on totals. Each needs one input that is not on the invoice: the order count, the minimum from the contract, and how you pay. A spreadsheet does not repeat the work for you. Every month brings new lines, and the checks that need history (R2, R13) get longer, not shorter.
What should you ask before you choose?
- For a percentage price: is the percentage taken on what is found, on what the 3PL agrees to credit, or on what reaches your account?
- Is there a minimum, a setup fee or a retainer, and how long does the agreement run?
- Which fee types and which months does the audit cover, and what happens to credits the 3PL would have given you anyway?
- Who writes to the 3PL, and do you see the claim before it goes?
- Do you receive the invoice lines behind each claim, or the total?
- For software: what sets the price, orders a month, invoices or what is found, and does the report say which checks could not run?
- For a spreadsheet: where do the rate card and its dates live, and who updates them when the contract changes?
Where does WareAudit fit, and what can you try without paying?
WareAudit is software at a fixed price. It has fourteen deterministic checks for invoices from ShipBob or ShipHero, runs every one the invoice data allows, says in the report when a check could not run, and writes the dispute letter for you to send. The sample report shows the output. A free audit of three invoices comes back within 48 hours. For the same work by hand, see how to audit a ShipHero invoice, line by line and what a rate card must say.
Sources
- WareAudit plan list, read 2026-10-30: plan prices, annual prices, order volumes, the one-off audit and the refund period.
- Audit providers' published price lists, October 2026: 25% and 35% of recovered shipping refunds (one list); from $1,000 a month with a zero setup fee (one list); no price shown on the other lists we read. Providers are not named.
- WareAudit list of checks and sample report: rule numbers, 606 lines billed at one wrong rate and 805 labels.
- What each rule needs: the WareAudit rule definitions for R1, R2, R4, R5, R8, R9, R10, R11, R12, R13, R14 and R15, as implemented on 2026-10-30.
Not legal or accounting advice.